TwentyFour Asset Management

AAAs Don’t Yield 2.3%, Do They?

TwentyFour Blog

Rates risk is not something we concern ourselves with too much in the European ABS market, so normally news of inverted yield curves and 30-year US Treasury yields dropping below 2% would largely wash over us. This is because pretty much all ABS bonds are floating rate, so there is no duration. Or is there?

A few years back when Euribor became a negative rate, someone came up with a brilliant idea called the ‘Euribor floor’. This was a more common feature in floating rate corporate, leveraged or real estate loans (and was more common in the US market), but it made perfect sense to introduce it to ABS deals backed by these ‘floored’ loans, such as CLOs and CMBS. And it was very well received by investors, as Euribor dropped below 0% and coupons remained stable, reducing the chief downside of floating rate bonds (a lower coupon when rates drop), and in effect creating (limited) duration.

For a number of years we have been able to ignore this feature, since Euribor has been steadily trading between -0.30% and -0.33%, and with swap rates mostly positive for longer bonds, the value of the floor was fairly stable.

This year, though, rates have dropped materially and with more European quantitative easing (QE) on the horizon, the floor’s value has increased significantly. Multiple researchers have recently written about why they like AAA rated CLO paper, and a lot of it has got to do with exactly this phenomenon – the Euribor floor is now significantly in the money. In fact, the value of today’s floor is worth over 50 basis points of extra spread, and for the coupon on these bonds to change, Euribor would have to increase by over 0.4%, which is great for valuations.

If we just look at AAA CLO bonds, as this is a deep and liquid market (compared to the relatively small CMBS market) and compare spread development to the most liquid AAA rated parts of the European ABS market (UK Prime, Dutch Prime and German Auto ABS), we can see that as bond prices haven’t moved materially, the value of the floor is not really being priced in.


Source: Morgan Stanley, 12 August 2019

Though AAA CLO bonds have been priced consistently at 107-112bp over (a floored) Euribor this year, the actual spreads have recently gone up considerably. As rates have dropped, the real spread over base rate of a primary AAA CLO tranche is now in the 140-150bp range, and around 130bp in secondary. By contrast, investors are “earning” Euribor plus 0.2% for holding Dutch RMBS, and while there is clearly a healthy Brexit premium in UK Prime RMBS, spreads in that market have also tightened materially versus CLOs since the start of the year.

The CLO market is deep and liquid, the AAAs are seen as the safe haven part, and they enjoy around 40% of hard credit support. Next to the yields on offer in broader European corporate credit, as in the table below, they look attractive given the risk.

Yield in: Euro GBP USD
AAA Euro CLO primary (Euribor/Libor + 1.5%) 1.1% 2.3% 3.7%
3-5 Year BBB Euro Corporate Index 0.4% 1.6% 3.2%
BB Euro HY Index 1.9% 3.1% 4.7%

Source: ICE-BAML, TwentyFour, 15 August 2019

While the rally in rates has resulted in compressed yields in the corporate credit markets, AAA CLO yield has remained at the same level, and in our view now offers a great deal of value without the downsides of duration.

TwentyFour Asset Management
TwentyFour Blog

Thomas Cook: A Warning to CLO Managers

The globally operating travel group Thomas Cook entered liquidation this week, after it was unable to reach an agreement between its shareholders, financiers and numerous creditors, leaving hundreds of thousands of travellers stranded. A potential restructuring would likely have resulted in a significant loss for bondholders, but now it looks like the senior unsecured bonds are virtually worthless – Debtwire expects a recovery of 0-10% and the bonds are now trading at around 6 cents.

Read more

TwentyFour Asset Management
TwentyFour Blog

$ Repo Rates Surge

There has been a bit of nervousness to say the least in US money markets over the last few days. The overnight repo rate in dollars surged to levels not seen since the aftermath of the financial crisis, touching almost 10% on Tuesday. During the financial crisis the high dollar repo rates were a clear sign of trouble in the banking system, so it’s natural that investors might be uneasy about this. We should stress upfront that this is not the case today, the spike in the repo rate is a short term technicality created by a confluence of events, none of which should be worrisome, but in which in aggregate created a shortage of dollar cash in a short space of time and over a very short period.

Read more